A candidate is a claim: how to audit Sudoku pencil marks
Learn the difference between a legal candidate, an omitted note and an actual deduction, with a reproducible audit procedure.
These examples describe a specific logical situation; verify the rules on your actual puzzle.
01Begin with a complete intersection
For an unsolved cell, start with digits 1–9. Remove every digit already found in the cell's row, column or 3×3 box. Suppose r5c5 sees 1,2,3 in its row, 4 and 6 in its column, and 7,8 in its box. It retains {5,9}; neither digit is proved. A tidy-looking note list is useful only if all the existing placements were considered.
02A pencil mark is not a placement
A candidate means the current constraints have not eliminated a digit. That is weaker than saying the digit must be placed in the cell. If you prefer 5 because the surrounding pattern looks symmetrical, you have added a guess rather than a proof. Seek a missing digit with a unique location in a unit, or a verified elimination pattern that rules out 9.
03Maintain the reasons for removals
After proving a 5 at another coordinate, remove 5 only from cells sharing its row, column or box. A more advanced technique can justify other removals, but record the name of the unit and the exact source candidates. If a cell has no candidate left, review the last placement or elimination instead of assuming an unsolvable puzzle immediately.
04Reproduce one deduction on paper
Select one row of a real Sudoku, list all its missing digits and map each digit to candidate positions. Check every candidate against its column and box. Place only what is forced; then repeat the map after the change. Your notes should allow another player to verify the reasoning independently.
Test your reasoning
If r5c5 allows {5,9} after all basic checks, does the presence of 5 in your notes justify filling it?
Show the answer
No. Both digits remain possible; an additional logical exclusion or uniqueness argument is needed.
Deeper practical examples and reasoning
A pencil mark means a digit has not yet been excluded, not that it must occupy that cell. Prove a hidden single by checking every other empty position in the unit; prove a naked single by excluding every competing digit in that one cell.
Distinguish 'not yet ruled out' from 'forced'
Suppose r5c5 retains {5,9}. The row, column and box checks have only established that neither value is currently forbidden. They have not established which one must be placed. Now look at the missing digit 9 across row 5. If that row still has three legal homes for 9, it gives no new information about r5c5. A real deduction may require a pair or another validated pattern elsewhere that removes 9 from the target. Keep this distinction explicit in your pencil marks.
How to explain an elimination to another person
A strong explanation names the target coordinate, the excluded digit, the source unit and the rule. For example, 'I removed 6 from r4c8 because a verified naked pair {6,8} occupies r4c2 and r4c5 in row 4.' A weak explanation says only 'the row looked full.' When a note is challenged, recheck the exact source candidate lists. Explainability is not optional ornamentation; it is how the player distinguishes logical solving from accidental correct guesses.